Fresh fruit and vegetables bring customers back to quick-commerce apps, and they also cause the most write-offs. Shrink, the gap between what a store receives and what it sells, is rarely one big failure. It builds up in small losses: a warm hour here, a crushed punnet there, a bunch of coriander that wilted on a shelf.
This post looks at where that value leaks out between the micro-fulfilment centre (MFC) shelf and the customer, and what buyers and store teams can do about it.
How big is the problem?
There is no published, audited shrink benchmark for Indian quick commerce. The closest reliable figures come from two places.
Indian supply chains overall. A study by NABARD Consultancy Services (NABCONS) for the Ministry of Food Processing Industries, covering 2020 to 2022, put annual post-harvest losses at about 7.36 million tonnes of fruit and 11.97 million tonnes of vegetables. Losses were highest for guava among fruits, at around 15%, and for tomato among vegetables, at around 11.6%. These figures cover the whole chain from farm to market, not stores alone.
Supermarket shrink abroad. The US Department of Agriculture's Economic Research Service compared produce received with produce sold across about 2,900 US supermarkets in 2011 to 2012. Average shrink was 12.6% for 24 fresh fruits and 11.6% for 31 fresh vegetables. Bananas were lowest at 4.1% and papayas highest at 43.1%. ERS notes that shrink is measured by weight and includes items removed for damage, overstocking, spoilage or poor appearance.
Neither figure applies directly to a dark store, but together they show the scale: in fresh produce, losing a tenth of what arrives is common unless the operation is actively managed.
Why the MFC model is different
Quick commerce removes some sources of shrink and adds others.
- Less customer handling. Shoppers do not squeeze tomatoes or drop mangoes, as they do in a supermarket.
- More small, fast picks. Pickers handle produce quickly to meet delivery promises, often from crowded racks.
- Many small stores. Redseer reports that mature metro stores need roughly 1,200 to 1,250 orders a day to break even, while non-metro stores average closer to 850. Lower order volume means slower stock turns for slow-moving fresh lines.
- Bike delivery. The last mile is short in time but often unrefrigerated, in Indian heat.
Where value leaks out
1. At receiving
Produce that arrives warm, over-ripe or with hidden defects starts losing value immediately. Kader of the University of California, Davis notes that above the optimum temperature, deterioration speeds up two to three times for every 10 °C rise. A crate that sat on a warm dock for an hour before put-away has already lost shelf life that the store cannot recover.
2. Wrong temperature zone
Not every item belongs in the same chiller. Kader groups produce into items best kept close to 0 to 2 °C (apples, broccoli, grapes, lettuce, pears) and chilling-sensitive items best kept at 5 to 15 °C depending on the item (avocado, banana, citrus, mango, melons, tomato). Chilling injury is cumulative and often only shows after the produce warms up: pitting, discolouration, uneven ripening or faster decay. A banana that spent a night in the wrong chiller may look fine at picking and turn grey at the customer's home.
3. Drying out
All fresh produce is mostly water. Kader identifies relative humidity, together with temperature, as the key to limiting water loss, recommending roughly 85 to 95% relative humidity for most fruit and 90 to 98% for most vegetables. Open racks under strong fan airflow dry out leafy greens, herbs and cut stems quickly. Wilting is a common reason produce is pulled from sale even though it is perfectly safe.
4. Ethylene and odour in shared storage
Small stores often keep everything close together. Ripening apples, pears, bananas and tomatoes release ethylene, which Kader notes can yellow broccoli and cucumber, cause russet spotting on lettuce and soften fruit. Strong-smelling onions and garlic can taint apples, citrus and grapes. Kader also points out that table grapes shipped with sulphur dioxide pads should be stored on their own.
5. Condensation
Moving produce in and out of cold rooms causes "sweating". Kader notes that condensation sitting on produce for long periods does more to encourage decay than humid air does. Punnets of berries and cherry tomatoes are particularly vulnerable.
6. Picking and packing
Crushing is the most visible last-step loss. Heavy items packed on top of soft fruit, berries placed in the bottom of a bag, or herbs folded into a tight corner all generate complaints and refunds. Trade press coverage of Indian quick commerce describes customers receiving produce that is "stale, smelly, or crushed", and points to insulated bagging for sensitive items as one fix.
7. The last mile
Very little research covers the trip from store to home. A study published in Acta Horticulturae by Chaiwong and Bishop, working with strawberries in the UK, found that an insulated bag slowed the rise in air temperature around pre-chilled fruit by about 20% and pulp temperature by about 10% over three hours, compared with an ordinary plastic bag. The authors noted how few studies exist on this stage. The principle carries over: chilled produce that leaves the store chilled and travels insulated arrives in better condition.
Practical steps to cut shrink
At the buying stage
- Specify ripeness, not just grade. For bananas, mangoes, avocados and pears, agree the colour stage or firmness you need for your sell-through window.
- Order to velocity. Smaller, more frequent drops of fast-perishing items such as leafy greens and berries usually beat larger weekly orders.
- Ask for uniform packs. Even-sized fruit in retail-ready packs reduces picking time and handling.
Inside the MFC
- Map items to temperature zones. Keep a simple chart on the chiller door showing which items go in each zone.
- Separate ethylene producers. Store ripening fruit away from greens and other sensitive items.
- Control humidity. Keep leafy greens covered or in perforated liners, and keep them out of direct fan airflow.
- Rotate strictly. First-expiring, first-out, checked daily.
- Track shrink by reason. Record whether each write-off was decay, damage, wilting, over-ripeness or expiry. The reason tells you whether to talk to the supplier, the store team or the delivery partner.
At picking and delivery
- Pack in order. Heavy and hard items first, soft fruit and herbs on top.
- Use insulated bags or sleeves for chilled and delicate items.
- Keep chilled items in the cold until the rider is ready, rather than staging them on a warm counter.
Questions to ask any supplier
- What temperature and ripeness stage will each item arrive at?
- Can you deliver smaller, more frequent drops for highly perishable lines?
- Can you pack to retail-ready units so pickers handle produce less?
- How do you separate ethylene-producing fruit from sensitive items in transit?
- What shelf life should we plan for once each item is received?
If you are working on fresh shrink in your stores and want to talk through specs, pack formats or delivery frequency, ask us for today's availability and a quote through the contact page.
Sources
- FreshPlaza, India reports high guava and tomato losses (NABCONS study for the Ministry of Food Processing Industries), August 2025. https://www.freshplaza.com/asia/article/9756104/india-reports-high-guava-and-tomato-losses/
- USDA Economic Research Service, Charts of Note: supermarket shrink for fresh fruits and vegetables (June 2016). https://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/charts-of-note/79033
- Adel A. Kader, Postharvest Technology of Horticultural Crops: An Overview from Farm to Fork, University of California, Davis. https://ucanr.edu/sites/Postharvest_Technology_Center_/files/231724.pdf
- S. Chaiwong and C.F.H. Bishop, Use of an Insulated Bag from the Supermarket to Maintain 'Elsanta' Strawberry Temperature to Households, Acta Horticulturae 1079 (2015). https://ishs.org/ishs-article/1079_20/
- Redseer Strategy Consultants, Quick commerce in India: scaling dark stores and growth. https://redseer.com/digests/quick-commerce-india-scale-dark-stores-growth/
- Shipsy, Fixing the dilemma: quality of fresh produce vs less than 45-minute deliveries. https://shipsy.io/blogs/quality-in-fresh-produce-quick-commerce/
